^Finished IMPACT25 Stop Motion^
The Impact 25 project was a fun but challenging experience. The challenge came from the group element of the project—not with each other but with the general public whom we tried tirelessly to solicit. Our project went through many transformations and challenged us to make on-the-spot decisions, venture from our comfort zones, and re-design our ideas when it became clear that our original ideas (and variations of those ideas) were not going to get us the outcome we had hoped.
The original project idea was to create a mural of sketches to represent the human spectrum of emotion. The platforms we were going to use were Reddit and Discord. We designed a prompt that asked random strangers in art/drawing-related groups to submit sketches representing their current emotions. We explained that upon gathering as many individual sketches as possible, we were going to combine them into one image which we would send back to participants as an update for them to see. We clarified that we were grad students working on a class project and that the work would not be shared beyond a single presentation at school to our classmates. We didn’t want people afraid of their identities or handles being shared so we said that the project would be anonymous. This, in hindsight, was probably our first mistake despite our good intentions.
We had only a couple of responders and they made it pretty clear that they considered our project to be “exploitative.” Upon this judgment, our post was basically shunned and we received no further comments, despite clarifying that anonymity was merely an option and that we were more than willing to credit artists in any way they wanted. We also found our luck limited on Discord and didn’t want to resort to asking friends as the “strangers” element of the project seemed important.
After about a week of trying these internet spaces for our project, we had a sobering conversation where we had to admit the failure of our efforts and start something from scratch. Because we had just had the stop motion unit, and we were very inspired by the Digital Stewards that week challenging us to all make a frame-by-frame animation together, we figured maybe it would actually be quite simple and fun to take Claymation to the streets. We scouted a good location right by the main Columbia campus, we brought some signage materials, a tripod, and a giant lump of clay. The clay was exciting—the non-drying flexible clay that is pretty standard for Claymation—unfortunately upon opening it the day of shooting, we found that it was as hard as a brick. It must have been sitting at the art store for eons. We tried to soften it as best as we could but it was not going anywhere and it was not the sort of clay you add water to. We determined that we’d do what we could with it, and people could prod at it to the best of their abilities—it just would not become anything more than abstract.
We set up the set and the lump of clay, the phone with the stop motion app on the tripod facing it. One of us (Justine) stood by the animation portion to teach people how stop motion works and what to do (touch the clay in some way for twelve times for twelve frames) while the other (Cara) bravely petitioned potential participants and explained to them the overall project and who we were.
We stood around for a few hours and only managed 8 participants. Most of them were frustrated at the dryness of the clay. One person lost interest when she realized we were working on an art project and not a “cleverly disguised pro-Palestine” after initially agreeing enthusiastically to participate. People also generally did not want to add their names or e-mails to the tally sheet—they seemed distrusting of this. As the hours wore on, the clay only seemed to harden more and we decided we needed to make another change to the project.
For the next long time, we simply asked people walking by if we could film their feet walking—hoping to cut the footage in between the Claymation footage to show the process of making art in the street, with people moving towards and away. We also decided that since most of these people were students trying to get to class and people hated signing their names before, we would simply make a tally of the remainder of participants to keep track. Finally, people responded well and were happy to contribute.
We were both very burnt out by the end of the day and a little bit embarrassed at how it all went down. We ceremoniously destroyed and disregarded our materials into the city trashcan, agreeing that the “process” was the true meaning of the project, and parted ways.
No comments:
Post a Comment