Tuesday, October 22, 2024

IMPACT 25

^Finished IMPACT25 Stop Motion^

The Impact 25 project was a fun but challenging experience. The challenge came from the group element of the project—not with each other but with the general public whom we tried tirelessly to solicit. Our project went through many transformations and challenged us to make on-the-spot decisions, venture from our comfort zones, and re-design our ideas when it became clear that our original ideas (and variations of those ideas) were not going to get us the outcome we had hoped.

 

The original project idea was to create a mural of sketches to represent the human spectrum of emotion. The platforms we were going to use were Reddit and Discord. We designed a prompt that asked random strangers in art/drawing-related groups to submit sketches representing their current emotions. We explained that upon gathering as many individual sketches as possible, we were going to combine them into one image which we would send back to participants as an update for them to see. We clarified that we were grad students working on a class project and that the work would not be shared beyond a single presentation at school to our classmates. We didn’t want people afraid of their identities or handles being shared so we said that the project would be anonymous. This, in hindsight, was probably our first mistake despite our good intentions.

 

We had only a couple of responders and they made it pretty clear that they considered our project to be “exploitative.” Upon this judgment, our post was basically shunned and we received no further comments, despite clarifying that anonymity was merely an option and that we were more than willing to credit artists in any way they wanted. We also found our luck limited on Discord and didn’t want to resort to asking friends as the “strangers” element of the project seemed important.

 

After about a week of trying these internet spaces for our project, we had a sobering conversation where we had to admit the failure of our efforts and start something from scratch. Because we had just had the stop motion unit, and we were very inspired by the Digital Stewards that week challenging us to all make a frame-by-frame animation together, we figured maybe it would actually be quite simple and fun to take Claymation to the streets. We scouted a good location right by the main Columbia campus, we brought some signage materials, a tripod, and a giant lump of clay. The clay was exciting—the non-drying flexible clay that is pretty standard for Claymation—unfortunately upon opening it the day of shooting, we found that it was as hard as a brick. It must have been sitting at the art store for eons. We tried to soften it as best as we could but it was not going anywhere and it was not the sort of clay you add water to. We determined that we’d do what we could with it, and people could prod at it to the best of their abilities—it just would not become anything more than abstract.

 

We set up the set and the lump of clay, the phone with the stop motion app on the tripod facing it. One of us (Justine) stood by the animation portion to teach people how stop motion works and what to do (touch the clay in some way for twelve times for twelve frames) while the other (Cara) bravely petitioned potential participants and explained to them the overall project and who we were.

 

We stood around for a few hours and only managed 8 participants. Most of them were frustrated at the dryness of the clay. One person lost interest when she realized we were working on an art project and not a “cleverly disguised pro-Palestine” after initially agreeing enthusiastically to participate. People also generally did not want to add their names or e-mails to the tally sheet—they seemed distrusting of this. As the hours wore on, the clay only seemed to harden more and we decided we needed to make another change to the project.

 

For the next long time, we simply asked people walking by if we could film their feet walking—hoping to cut the footage in between the Claymation footage to show the process of making art in the street, with people moving towards and away. We also decided that since most of these people were students trying to get to class and people hated signing their names before, we would simply make a tally of the remainder of participants to keep track. Finally, people responded well and were happy to contribute.

 

We were both very burnt out by the end of the day and a little bit embarrassed at how it all went down. We ceremoniously destroyed and disregarded our materials into the city trashcan, agreeing that the “process” was the true meaning of the project, and parted ways.



Cara’s Individual Thoughts 

Justine’s Individual Thoughts 

As our presentation stated, our Impact25 project started out as an idea to make a digital collage. I enjoyed the digital collage process so much that I wanted to do another one for the midterm. Justine was on board, and we brainstormed that the prompt had to be something abstract yet concrete and up to individual interpretation. We came up with feelings. I sent a posting out to Reddit on r/drawingrprompts explaining we are students from TC, looking for makers to send us a visual representation of what emotion they were feeling. I gave them two weeks to do this until I would collect the art because the Reddit account is under my name. We got absolutely nothing. 

Reddit was a dead end. I did, however, receive two nasty comments about how I should go to an anime con instead or not ask people for art for free. I will withhold any bad language from this reflection because I was cursing the internet deities out for this. Honestly, Reddit sucks. I was really not expecting such backlash, and neither was Justine. We reconvened last week to change our project direction entirely. Justine came up with the stop motion idea, and I jumped on because I also enjoyed making my own at home from last week’s homework. Justine supplied the clay and film equipment, and I made flyers and a poster to advertise. The goal of the stop motion was to film 25 different people interacting/changing the clay. We would film only the clay, but we have a list of participants.  

On a Friday, Justine and I set up and waited. We naturally fell into two separate yet imperative roles. Justine managed the technology, explained how to do the project to strangers, and guided them through the art process. Since I made the advertisements, I became the spokesperson. I tried calling out a fun, fast art project…come do art…animation project here…literally everything under the Sun. At most times, I was completely ignored. I definitely preferred it when someone told me they were late or rushing to a class. We only managed to get 8 participants to work with the clay. At this point, we changed direction again. Justine set up the camera and filmed people passing by instead (with their permission).

Throughout this process, we had to evolve the project to fit strangers. Since Reddit was a dead end, we opted to do an in-person activity in the heart of a bustling college area…which resulted in not-great results. When I think about it, given the state of the world, people just aren’t open to helping others out these days, and it’s honestly quite disheartening. I know that if the roles were reversed, I would personally love to help out with an art project. I’m glad we produced a video at least. What I learned from this process is that trying to reach out to strangers in this day is impossible. No one seems to want to help anyone else or give a few minutes of their time. I think if we were to retry this project, we’d do a Google survey thing where people can submit art there, and we would send it out to people we knew (like classmates, family, or friends). 

Overall, I’m glad to have worked with Justine because she came up with many ideas on the spot when we had to shift gears. I’m also glad this was a flexible project. While our outcome wasn’t what we intended, it’s interesting to see the results of what happened. This was a very challenging midterm project, and I enjoyed how I was pushed to my limits. Dealing with strangers online is no fun! 

I won’t lie and say that this was an entirely pleasant experience, but at least working with Cara was very pleasant and parts of it were quite fun. We came up with some ideas that we thought were alright but were challenged the whole way through, so we had to problem solve and make decisions that took some amount of quick brainstorming with an open mind. 


I was disheartened but also not extremely surprised that people acted the way they did on the internet towards our request. Despite the fact that we had good intentions, Reddit is an especially toxic place. I think it’s a little sad that in modern times, people’s first reaction towards strangers is to be suspicious. I’m not saying that I am any different, we all have very good reasons to be suspicious because there are a lot of bad people out there looking to exploit others, but that as a fact in itself is the sad part. We’ve created a world where we all feel safer being cold and distanced from others and we miss some cool opportunities to build community and camaraderie in the process. 


When we took our project to the streets and changed it to claymation, I was very frustrated that the clay I bought was so hard and impossible to work with. I have worked with claymation before and I got the same clay as I did before that had never given me any problems, so it was a bummer. Eventually we just decided to make due with it, but it was a shame because I feel like the participants didn’t get to express themselves the way they could with softer clay and a few of them were a bit snarky about it, as if I had personally planned to bring bad clay. 


Cara did a great job advertising the project on the streets and I was and am very thankful for her for doing that during the process because she has a much friendlier voice than I do and it was a very nerve-wracking thing to do. 


Switching to doing stop motion of the feet walking by felt kind of sad but at the same time it seemed fitting. It shows the movement of the city juxtaposed with our attempts to slow it down.


This project didn’t go the way we planned but by the end, we realized that this was actually kind of the cool part of it. We got to exercise a lot of quick thinking and we also learned a little bit about how closed off society can be. I admitted to Cara at some point that I probably wouldn’t have stopped for us either, and this realization really made me think about what kind of artist I want to be and how I can evolve to be more supportive in my day-to-day life of the harmless creative pursuits of strangers. It was a sobering experience.


I’m glad I got to work with Cara. She had great ideas for our project, she thought very creatively, she was kind to the public in ways I struggle with and she made the best signage and flyers. She was really fun to work with and was great at problem-solving. It was a difficult project but I know with certainty that we exercised our critical thinking and creativity, and that we did our best despite unforeseen roadblocks.



No comments:

Post a Comment