Tuesday, October 8, 2024

Response to Kylie Peppler’s 2013 report New Opportunities for Intert-driven Arts Learning in a Digital Age

Kylie Peppler’s 2013 report New Opportunities for Intert-driven Arts Learning in a Digital Age explores the trajectory of technology in the arts and seeks to offer an optimistic perspective, making claims that technology may provide solutions to inequities in art education, stimulate more youth to explore the arts, and offer somewhat of a rejuvenation to the arts in fitting with our modern times. 

This report was pretty much exactly as I expected it to be as there have been many articles written just like this since technology in the arts first erupted. You could throw a rock in any art class, party, or out the window and hit five people who will have a long passionate discourse with you covering basically every bullet point this report contains and their personal opinions of them. Yes, technology makes art more accessible, provides alternative methods that some may find more useful or interesting, and opens the doors to new forms and manipulations of art as we know it. I won’t argue with that because it’s true, but I also don’t really want to talk about it because it’s boring. We’ve all said all there is to say about this and I just thank Christ that this report was written in 2013 and not this year so it doesn’t have an AI section. 

What does interest me is the position that language has over how we ingest information. There are certain word choices that, while subtle, manipulate our perceptions of what we are reading or hearing. This report uses descriptors for physical art-making such as “respected historical methods,” “analog”, and “old forms”—words we usually use to describe things that are becoming or have become antiquated. These are not descriptors of something that is “happening now,” so it forces us to regard these forms of art as no longer relevant and boring, even if we don’t realize it. Meanwhile, technology in the arts “reinvigorates,” “re-envisions,” and adds “new dimensions,” as if art was on life support waiting to be saved by technology. 

Later in the report, Peppler writes in regards to young people and traditional music making “…it is not always something young people have the time, money, or inclination to do.” and follows this up with digital music technologies and softwares being the solution to these barriers. Because we see “time” and “money” first, the author has earned our sympathy, so we don’t really read into what “inclination” means in this context. What does it mean? That young people who don’t care enough about music to put the effort in to learn how to do it should still get to be musicians? Why? If they don’t have an “inclination” for music, then are we just forging egos and identities to display? This sentiment is a thread throughout the report; everybody should be able to be artists no matter what—no matter how much time they want to put in, how they spend their money (Peppler talks about the high cost of traditional materials but conveniently leaves out the cost of suitable computers for making digital art and music in 2013), or if they even really care. Of course, true artists are utilizing these tools, but there seems to be a strong suggestion that being a true artist no longer matters because anybody can do anything no matter what. If everything is sacred then nothing is.

Additionally, I couldn’t help but notice in the animation section of this report, when speaking of traditional forms of animation, Peppler lists flip-books and stop motion using “Lego,” “clay,” “toys,” and “paper cut-outs” specifically. Why would Lego be the first example of stop motion? Lego was never one of the more popular or relevant tools. And what about toys? Why are props and figures labeled toys when they exist in the physical realm? Interestingly, Peppler can’t straight-up use the words puppetry, models, or claymation, she had to make traditional animation sound as infantile as possible. Meanwhile, using technology “places animation within a contemporary art practice as a real art form[…]” and she includes a long list of all the differing tools and software one can use, including cameras, as if using a camera is not something people did in animation before. This evokes the image of a traditional animator tinkering around with a stick man flip book and a pile of Lego to show his mom later, while a digital animator is professional, creative, and cutting-edge.

I think this report is a great example of a seemingly innocuous exploration of the positive impact of technology on the arts, aimed at dispelling the fear traditional artists have of fine art becoming obsolete in the next generations. I’m not saying there is a sinister undertone, but I do notice that there is certain language used to subtly manipulate us onto a certain side and I do believe there is a side, as this is a commissioned report. The commissioner of the report is The Wallace Foundation, a foundation whose mission is “to help all communities build a more vibrant and just future by fostering advances in the arts, education leadership, and youth development.”  This is great and I’m not implying otherwise, but something interesting is that the president of this foundation is a man named Will Miller, who is also a board member of a Fortune500 technology manufacturing company. Because of this, I am suggesting that there is at least some intention behind the way fine-art was described in this report versus art using technology. I think financial ties to manufacturing technology seem like a good reason to make sure people see technology as the future of art, which this report has successfully conveyed. Regardless of this report's prime directive, it served as a reminder to me to always be aware of the things I read--not just for the information that is written but for how that information is written as well.


No comments:

Post a Comment